Financial law and financial science in Russian Federation and Czech Republic (comparative research)

The methodology. Comparative legal, historical and analytical scientific methods were used. The main results, scope of application. Formation of financial-legal theory in both countries took place under the circumstances of political changes. In relation to the Czechoslovak Republic, the attention is focused on the period from the formation of the Czechoslovak Republic in 1918 to the formation of the Czech Republic in 1993, and the main emphasis is made on the period of the 21st century. Periodization of financial law and financial science, and also the system of financial law considers the teaching of financial law and financial science at the Faculty of Law, Charles University. The study also characterizes the process of development of financial law and financial science in pre-revolutionary Russia, highlights the Soviet period of development of financial law, focuses on the problems of development of modern financial law. Periodization of financial law, as well as the system of financial law, are presented from the perspective of teaching of the subject of financial law at the faculties of law. The authors suppose that the modern system of financial law and financial science has retained the original division into two parts, general and specific. All sub-branches of the special part of financial law may be divided into three main blocks: (1) sub-branches of the fiscal part of financial law; (2) sub-branches of the non-fiscal part of financial law; common sub-branches of the non-fiscal part of financial law.

Conclusions. The hypothesis about the unity of the principles of financial law and financial science, and public finance as the main category, as well as about the independence of this branch of public law was confirmed during the study. Due to the growing volume of legal regulation in both countries, the historical division of the financial law system is not enough, there is an extensive fragmentation of division in the financial law system. We are observing the emergence of new sub-branches, which are likely to tend to the formation of new branches.

1. Gerloch A. Teorie práva [Theory of Law], 6th ed. Plzeň, Aleš Čeněk Publ., 2013. 310 p. (In Czech).

2. Funk V. Finanční věda se zvláštním zřetelem k československému zákonodárství finančnímu 1922-1929 [Financial Science with a Focus on Czechoslovak Financial Law of 1922-1929]. Prague, Smichov, VŠEHRD Publ., 2015. 432 p. (In Czech).

3. Englis K. Finanční věda [Financial Sciences]. Brno, Brno Publishing House, 1929. 407 p. (In Czech).

4. Vybral V. Nástin československého práva finančního [Topics in Czechoslovak financial law]. Prague, Brno, Orbis Publ., 1934. 41 p. (In Czech).

5. Úvod do studia finanční vědy a českého finančního práva. I. Obecná část [Introduction to the study of financial sciences and Czech financial law. Part I. General part]. Prague, VŠEHRD Publ., 1994. 135 p. (In Czech).

6. Úvod do studia finanční vědy a českého finančního práva. II. Zvláštní část [Introduction to the study of financial sciences and Czech financial law. Part II. Special part]. Prague, VŠEHRD Publ., 1995. 212 p. (In Czech).

7. Spacil B. Československé finanční právo [Czechoslovak Financial Law]. Prague, Orbis Publ., 1959. 416 p. (In Czech).

8. Spacil B. et al. Finanční právo ČSSR [Financial law of Czechoslovakia]. Prague, State Pedagogical publishing house, 1965. 185 p. (In Czech)

9. Karfíkova M. Teorie finančního práva a finanční vědy [Theory of financial law and financial science]. Prague, Wolters Kluwer CR Publ., 2018. 356 p. (In Czech).

10. Bakes M. et al. Československé finanční právo [Czechoslovak Financial Law]. Prague, Panorama Publ., 1979. 312 p. (In Czech).

11. Bakes M. et al. Československé finanční právo [Czechoslovak Financial Law]. Prague, Ustav statní spravy Publ., 1987. 371 p. (In Czech).

12. Bakes M. et al. Finanční právo [Financial law], 2nd ed. Prague, C.H. Beck Publ., 1999. 416 p. (In Czech).

13. Nemecek E. Úvod do studia finanční politiky [Introduction to Financial Policy Research]. Prague, VSEHRD Publ., 2001. 61 p. (In Czech).

14. Bakeš M. et al. Finanční právo [Financial law], 4th ed. Prague, C.H. Beck, 2006. 741 p. (In Czech).

15. Králik J., Jakubovič D. Finančné právo [Financial Law]. Bratislava, VEDA Publ., 2004. 725 p. (In Slovak).

16. Funk V. Finanční věda, se zvláštním zřetelem k československému zákonodárství fiančnímu [Financial science, with special regard to the Czechoslovakian legislation]. Prague, VŠEHRD Publ., 1926. 97 p. (In Czech).

17. Gerloch A. Teorie práva [Theory of Law], 2nd ed. Dobra Voda, Aleš Čeněk Publ., 2001. 299 p. (In Czech).

18. Sonnenfels J. von. Gründsatze der Polizei, Handungs und Finanzwissenschaft [Fundamentals of Police, Trade, and Financial Science]. Vienna, 1764. 309 p. (In German).

19. Karfíkova M. Alois Rašín, in: Antologie československé právní vědy v letech 1918-1939 [Anthology of Czechoslovak Legal Science in 1918-1939], Prague, Linde Publ., 2009, pp. 637–639. (In Czech).

20. Karfíkova M. Karel Englis, in: Antologie československé právní vědy v letech 1918-1939 [Anthology of Czechoslovak Legal Science in 1918-1939], Prague, Linde Publ., 2009, pp. 576–582. (In Czech).

21. Rašin A. Můj finanční plán [My financial plan]. Prague, Prazska akciova tiskarna Publ., 1920. 208 p. (In Czech).

22. Sousa J. Daně a poplatky v 19. století a za Československé republiky [Taxes and levies in the 19th century and during the Czechoslovak Republic], in: Stary M. et al. Dějiny daní a poplatků [History of taxes and fees], Prague, Havlíček Brain Team Publ., 2009, pp. 124–133. (In Czech).

23. Engliš K. Finanční věda [Financial Science]. Prague, Borovy Publ., 1929. 407 p. (In Czech).

24. Karfíkova M. Soustava státních příjmů v letech 1952-1970 [The system of state revenues in 1952-1970], in: Stary M. et al. Dějiny daní a poplatků [History of taxes and fees], Prague, Havlíček Brain Team Publ., 2009, pp. 172–180. (In Czech).

25. Spáčil B. Teorie finančního práva ČSSR [The theory of financial law of the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic]. Prague, Orbis Publ., 1970. 176 p. (In Czech).

26. Slovinsky A., Girasek J. Československé finančné právo [Czechoslovak Financial Law]. Bratislava, Obzor Publ., 1974. 390 p. (In Slovak).

27. Frinta O. Private law in the Czech Republic development, availability and prospects, in: Moon J., Tomasek M. et al. A law that crosses Eurasia. From Korea to the Czech Republic, Passau, Berlin, Prague, RW&W Science & NewMedia Publ., 2015, pp. 63–89.

28. Frintová D., Frinta O., Chroma M. Selected issues of family law recodification in the Czech Republic, in: Tomasek M. et al. Czech law between Europeanization and globalization, Prague, Charles University in Prague Publ., Karolinum Press, 2010, pp. 317–327.

29. Khalfina R.O. Issues of Soviet administrative and financial law. Moscow, Academy of Sciences of the USSR Publ., 1952. 214 p. (In Russ.).

30. Ivanov B.N. On the system of Soviet financial law. Trudy VYuZI, 1967, vol. IX, pp. 40–41. (In Russ.).

31. Piskotin M.I. Soviet Budget Law. The main problems. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ., 1971. 312 p. (In Russ.).

32. Tsypkin S.D. Revenues of the state budget of the USSR. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ., 1973. 222 p. (In Russ.).

33. Vilnyanskii S.I. On the question of the system of Soviet law. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pravo, 1957, no. 1, pp. 107–109. (In Russ.).

34. Gurvich M.A. Soviet Financial law. Moscow, Gosyurizdat Publ., 1954. 324 p. (In Russ.).

35. Rovinskii E.A. Basic questions of the theory of Soviet financial law. Moscow, Gosyurizdat Publ., 1960. 193 p. (In Russ.).

36. Khimicheva N.I. Subjects of budget law. Saratov, Saratov University Publ., 1978. 222 p. (In Russ.).

37. Khudyakov A.I. Selected works on financial law. St. Petersburg, Yuridicheskii Tsentr-Press Publ., 2010. 272 p. (In Russ.).

38. Bescherevnykh V.V. Competence of the USSR in the field of budget. Moscow, Yuridicheskaya literatura Publ., 1976. 176 p. (In Russ.).

39. Gracheva E.Yu. To the question of the essence of financial law, in: Pokachalova E.V. (ed.). Federal'nye i regional'nye aspekty finansovogo prava, A round table dedicated to the 75th anniversary of Academician N.I. Khimicheva, abstracts of speeches (October 2-3, 2003), Saratov, 2004, pp. 11–14. (In Russ.).

40. Gerloch A. Teorie práva [The theory of law], 3rd ed. Pilsen, Aleš Cenek Publ., 2004. 343 p. (In Czech).

41. C. Bakeš M., Karfíková M., Kotáb P., Marková H., et al. Finanční právo [Financial Law], 6th ed. Prague, H. Beck Publishing House Publ., 2012. 549 p. (In Czech).