The helplessness of the victim: theoretical views and law enforcement practice

The subject of the study is the helplessness of the victim as a criminal legal category.  The purpose of the research is to confirm the hypothesis about the negative impact of the evaluative nature of the sign "helpless state of the victim" on the unity of law practice. The historical and legal method allows us to consider doctrinal views and case law of applying norms containing the helpless state of the victim in different historic periods; using the comparative legal method, differences in the interpretation of the victim's helpless in different criminal laws are revealed; the formal legal method allows us to explore the technique of legislative recognition of the helpless state of the victim as constructive, qualifying signs and aggravating circumstances; logical methods contribute to the gener- alization of the results of the analysis of case law.

The main results. It is established that the existing definitions of the helpless state of the victim, as a rule, are based on the objective inability of the person to actively resist. Based on the various reasons that cause the helpless of the victim, the following types are distinguished: physical and mental. Two categories of persons are recognized as physically helpless: those who are unable to resist due to internal factors (state of health) and external (related persons). The list of diseases that form physical helplessness is open. However, the court, as a rule, refers to disability or difficulties in movement. It is important when imputing physical helplessness to establish the fact that the victim was in such a state before the start of the committing of the criminal intent. Otherwise, it forms the objective side of the crime. The court, when determining mental helplessness, mainly focuses on the expert opinion. A controversial issue in the doctrine of criminal law remains the attribution of unconsciousness to helpless state in crimes against life and health. The Court takes the position of not attributing. In this case, it seems illogical to recognize a bound person as helpless.In order to maintain the unity of practice, a critical analysis of the approaches existing in the theory of criminal law, the grounds for strengthening criminal responsibility for a crime against a helpless person, has been carried out. These include: method, protection of socially poorly protected groups, peculiar ferocity, provoking factor, cynicism. Taking into account the specifics of crimes against sexual freedom and sexual inviolability and against life and health, it seems more logical to formulate different grounds for them: as a way of committing a crime and as protection of socially poorly protected groups, respectively.

Conclusions. The hypothesis about the lack of unity in doctrine and law enforcement practice regarding the content of the "helpless state" sign of the victim was confirmed. It should be noted that the existing discussion is largely due to the ambiguous position of the Russian Supreme Court. In order to resolve the existing contradictions, it is proposed to determine the fundamental point: the basis for strengthening criminal responsibility.

1. Borodin S.V. Liability for Murder: Classification and Punishment Under Russian Law. Moscow, Yurist Publ., 1994. 216 p. (In Russ.).

2. Kondrashova T.V. Problems of Criminal Liability for Crimes Against Life, Health, Sexual Freedom and Sexual Inviolability. Yekaterinburg, Humanitarian University Publ., 2000. 348 p. (In Russ.).

3. Lopashenko N.A. Minors and other persons in a vulnerable state as victims of aggravated murder (Art. 105 (2) (c) of the RF Criminal Code). Biblioteka ugolovnogo prava i kriminologii = Library of criminal law and criminology, 2013, no. 1 (1), pp. 59−73. (In Russ.).

4. Semerneva N.K. Determining the Nature of Crimes (General and Special Parts). Moscow, Prospekt Publ., Yekaterinburg, Ural State Law Academy Publ., 2010. 296 p. (In Russ.).

5. Topil’skaya E.V. The Helpless State of the Victim of a Crime, Cand. Diss. Thesis. St. Petersburg, 1992. 25 p. (In Russ.)

6. Bezmaternykh M.A., Kachina N.V. The Joint Use of Peculiarities of Such Elements as the “Use of Violence” and “Abuse of Helpless Condition of the Victim” When Qualifying the Acts Provided for under Articles 131 and 132 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Aktual'nye problemy rossiiskogo prava = Actual Problems of Russian Law, 2018, no. 12 (97), pp. 142−149. DOI: 10.17803/1994-1471.2018.97.12.142-149. (In Russ.).

7. Burkina O.A., Kotelnikova E.A. The signs of the victim in the criminal law (Art. 134 and 135 of the Criminal Code). Ugolovnoe pravo, 2010, no. 2, pp. 21−23. (In Russ.).

8. Gorbatova M.A. A helpless victim in criminal law and judicial practice: certain aspects of classification. Ugolovnoe pravo, 2017, no. 5, pp. 39−42. (In Russ.).

9. Shiyan V.I. The helpless state of a victim as an objective element of violent crimes against a person. Ugolovnoe pravo, 2014, no. 5, pp. 103–105. (In Russ.).

10. Bulikeeva D.Zh. Problems of application of a qualifying sign "other person, obviously for guilty being down and out". Vestnik Chelyabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta = Bulletin of Chelyabinsk State University, 2013, no. 17 (308): Law, iss. 37, pp. 54−57. (In Russ.).

11. Kozachenko E.B. The notion «helpless state» in doctrinal and law enforcement interpretations. Rossiiskii yuridicheskii zhurnal = Russian Juridical Journal, 2011, no. 4 (79), pp. 145−153. (In Russ.).

12. Peshkov D.V. On the question of qualifying the murder of intoxicated or sleeping persons. Simvol nauki = Symbol of Science, 2017, no. 11, pp. 54−57. (In Russ.).

13. Plaksina T.A. Grounds for strengthening liability for the murder of a person known to be in a helpless state. Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Pravovedenie, 2005, no. 1, pp. 151−159. (In Russ.).

14. Khatuev V.B. Criminally-legal value of special qualities of the victim as aggravating circumstances. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 11: Pravo = Moscow University Bulletin. Series 11. Law, 2017, no. 3, pp. 40−60. (In Russ.).

15. Barysheva K.A. Collisions in Legal Interpreting the Victim Helplessness Signs in Different Crimes. Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki = Law. Journal of the Higher School of Economics, 2016, no. 4, pp. 118−128. DOI: 10.17323/2072-8166.2016.4.118.128. (In Russ.).

16. Gostkova D.Zh., Shtefan A.V. Physical helplessness of the aggrieved: the position of the court. Advokatskaya praktika = Advocate’s Practice, 2022, no. 1, pp. 35–39. (In Russ.).

17. Davtyan D.V. Some Questions about the Concept of a Helpless State. Vestnik Volgogradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya 5: Yurisprudentsiya = Science Journal of Volgograd State University. Jurisprudence, 2006, no. 8, pp. 143−145. (In Russ.).

18. Isayev N.A. Victim of a crime in a helpless condition: state of law and issues of law enforcement practice. Evraziiskii yuridicheskii zhurnal = Eurasian Law Journal, 2015, no. 2 (81), pp. 162−163. (In Russ.).

19. Kaufman M.A. Age-related features of a victim: disputable aspects of criminal and legal regulation. Ugolovnoe pravo, 2015, no. 4, pp. 19−26. (In Russ.).

20. Lobanova L.V., Davtyan D.V. The question of notion "juvenile victim" and its criminal and legal meaning. Ugolovnoe pravo, 2010, no. 6, pp. 31−34. (In Russ.).

21. Repiev A.G. Enforcement of rights and legal interests of people when their applications and reports are handled by a police commissioner: regional aspect. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo = Tomsk State University Journal of Law, 2016, no. 2 (20), pp. 54−60. DOI: 10.17223/22253513/20/7. (In Russ.).

22. Sharapov R.D., Smahtin E.V. New Grounds of Criminal Liability for Inducement to Suicide and other LifeThreatening Behavior. Vserossiiskii kriminologicheskii zhurnal = Russian Journal of Criminology, 2018, vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 349–357. DOI: 10.17150/2500-4255.2018.12(3).349-357. (In Russian).

23. Kravchuk O.V., Atamanchuk V.M., Turovets Y.M., Volkotrub S.H., Ostapenko O.Ye. The Essence of the Helpless State of Persons as an Important Component in the Investigation of Crimes. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 2021, vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 269−276. DOI: 10.37635/jnalsu.28(2).2021.269-276.

24. Plaksina T.A. The regulation of liability for murder in legislations of Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Mongolia: comparative legal study. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Pravo = Tomsk State University Journal of Law, 2015, no. 3 (17), pp. 48−57. DOI: 10.17223/22253513/16/7. (In Russ.).

25. Skikula I.R. Theoretical and practical problems of the definition of «helpless state» in the criminal law of Russia. Vestnik Kazanskogo yuridicheskogo instituta MVD Rossii = Bulletin of the Kazan Law Institute of MIA of Russia, 2016, no. 3 (25), pp. 78−81. (In Russ.).

26. Dydo A.V. Sexual Assault: Problems of Criminal and Legal Assessment, Cand. Diss. Thesis. Vladivostok, 2006. 214 p. (In Russ.).

27. Doronina E.B. The Helpless State of the Victim in the Structure of Murder, Cand. Diss. Thesis. Yekaterinburg, 2004. 177 p. (In Russ.).

28. Byhanova K.V. On the question of consciousness and the unconscious. Vestnik nauki, 2019, vol. 3, no. 5 (14), pp. 80−83. (In Russ.).

29. Shaldyaeva E.G., Rozuman I.V. Medical aspects of evaluation of sleep as helpless state of the victim at the moment of murder. Vestnik sudebnoi meditsiny = Bulletin of forensic medicine, 2017, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 27–31. (In Russ.).

30. Dementev S. The Concept of Helpless and Unconscious State. Rossiiskaya yustitsiya, 1999, no. 1, p. 43. (In Russ.).